About
Vibrant eatery & bar with Mexican-American fare. A menu of Mexican & American dishes like tacos & burgers in a lively, relaxed restaurant with a bar.
Features & Amenities
No features listed
Customer Reviews
Disappointed with Our Experience We brought a large group of 45 people to Rookies and were extremely disappointed. It was clear from the start that they were not prepared for a party of our size, even though it had been communicated ahead of time. There was only one server assigned to our entire group, which led to slow service, cold food, and a lot of frustration. We specifically came for the all-you-can-eat taco bar, but were told it wasn’t available because it had to be pre-ordered — something that was never made clear when we booked. That was one of the main reasons we chose this place, so to be told it wasn’t an option was frustrating. To top it off, the food was overpriced for the quality and the overall experience did not match the expectations. Would not recommend for large parties or group events. Definitely won’t be back
I made a reservation for 40 people for our baseball team and family members to meet for lunch during our Dreams Park tournament. Making the reservation was fast and easy. In fact, our first reservation had to be postponed by a day due to rain delays and Rookie's contacted me to offer to reschedule because they anticipated that we would need to before I even got the chance to call them. When we arrived, they were immediately ready for us. They allowed each family to have separate checks, which makes group meals a lot easier. Our waitress was clearly prepared and experienced with groups. It was a lot for her to deal with, but she worked very hard and the meal went very smoothly. My grilled chicken wrap was very good. The menu is extremely kid friendly. The arcade is cool. I highly recommend Rookie's for a big group.
Great for teams and families! Good food, reasonable prices and you can't beat the arcade. Kids can have fun while adults relax with a drink. Perfectly located in the heart of a baseball town.
Business Information
Address
4850 NY-28, Cooperstown, NY 13326
Hours
Hours not available
Information on this page has been aggregated from public sources. Data may not be current or accurate. Please contact the business directly to confirm details.Last updated: 1/5/2026
Technology for the game indoors.